Dan - I've been dealing with Tyler up at (Discount Tire) and looks like we're looking at the same thing. I'm going the Hankook 265/60/R18. I debated the 265/65 but didn't want to put up with any rubbing at all. I've got a 2013 LR4 with 20's as stock and have ruined 3 sidewalls over 2 years - and now after a week of off-roading in Moab, I've been convinced to go the 18's.
I'm actually trying the new wheel Tyler researched for me - guess I'm the guinea pig on this one. I was very close to ordering the Compo's ...
The wheel is an American Racing ATX194. I've gone the Matt black with black Teflon. Supposedly it came out in the last 30 days which is why it hasn't hit mainstream yet. They are coming in at well under $200 per wheel ... hopefully I'm getting them fitted Friday. So either they work, or I'm on the Compo website.
I'll post again once they get fitted as I know a bunch of guys here would appreciate a local supplier.