Okay...I think things are correcting. Maybe this was off due to whatever fuel or driving had been going on while Carmax had the vehicle.
I had a 1/2 tank left of whatever the dealership had in there, filled it with Super and went for a 2 hour drive on the highway; 1/2 traffic, 1/2 fast, some back roads - computer came up with 18.2MPG and my hand computation came up with 17.2 MPG. Seems good to me under the circumstances.
I'll see how around town driving performs.
@Surfrider77 , that's pretty good. It's what my LR3 would show after several months of forgetting about it. That (for me) meant 17-20 highway and whatever it got around town.