
This is the kind of stuff that makes me sad. It's why I generally advocate getting your parts not from the cheapest source but buying 'cheap' parts from a reliable source (parts stores where you can see someone or some place that is a solid part of the Land Rover Community). Internet reviews can be made up by people who have a vested interest in a seller.
See if you can return it, make sure you read all the fine print of the place you bought it from, they may have something in writing that protects them, but don't ACCEPT it if you thought you were getting something new and received that.
Good luck!
EDIT: As a 'oh by the way' Keep a look out for those kinds of parts on places like eBay and Craigslist especially where people are selling 're-manufactured used' parts. They're using a wording trick to get away with saying something was used, you purchased it used and they sold you a used unit so it's all legit. eBay had this problem years and years ago and a lot of their auctions now have the settings for how used or new an item is such as 'new in the box never opened' or 'new no tags'. Where there is a will there is a way in the scammers world though!

.