If I was sticking with 19" wheels and an "all-arounder" tire for my next go-around, I'd probably get the Coopers again.
Like I said, not really loud, especially for an all-terrain tire. Yeah, they are louder than the Michelins they replaced, but those are probably as quiet as it gets.
They did really well in Colorado last summer, with no problems on the trails around Ouray and Lake City. I don't air them down off road because that's just asking for sidewall damage on a 19" tire, but they still did really well.
They do okay in the snow. Okay in the rain. Etc.
As it is, though, I'm thinking I'll go with 18" wheels for my next off-road set of tires, then maybe put some dedicated street tires on the 19" wheels. These Coopers look to have over 20k miles left, though, so there's no rush.
can you air down the 19" duratracs or is it best to keep them at recommended psi?